Aaron Hicks, Luis Severino deals are Yankees disasters: Sherman

Aaron Hicks performed in 137 video games in 2018, a Ripken-esque quantity for him. The Yankees signed him for seven years at $70 million the next February. He has performed 145 video games within the three seasons since.

Luis Severino began 63 video games between 2017-18, the identical as Jacob deGrom, yet another than Corey Kluber, two fewer than Gerrit Cole. He acquired Cy Young consideration each seasons and was an All-Star every year. The Yankees signed him to a four-year, $40 million pact a number of days earlier than rewarding Hicks. He has began 5 instances since, twice within the 2019 playoffs, none in both of the final two seasons. He is, at minimum, a month away.

The Yanks had gone underneath the luxury-tax threshold in 2018, resetting the penalty proportion. Thus, they had been keen in multiyear extensions to pay Hicks and Severino a little bit extra for 2019, believing they might be rewarded long run. Those contracts have been disasters, as a lot now as ever because the harm absences exacerbate Yankee points.

It was not customary for the Yanks to increase Hicks and Severino. The Yanks had usually waited till gamers reached free company to enlist them long run. Over the earlier quarter century, that they had solely acted early seven instances and 4 had been for the Core Four — Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada and Mariano Rivera. After buying Tino Martinez from the Mariners, the Yanks needed to indicate a monetary and emotional dedication to the primary base successor to Don Mattingly. Robinson Cano and Brett Gardner had been the opposite two.

All seven had varied ranges of success and none was an outright monetary sinkhole, like Hicks and Severino have been to this point. The Yanks are again making an attempt to remain underneath a luxury-tax threshold, making the $20 million Hicks and Severino value detrimental to roster building. The Yanks undertaking to roughly $207 million for this season and the brink is $210 million.

 New York Yankees starting pitcher Luis Severino #40, throws during practice
Luis Severino
Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post

The Yanks will most likely have so as to add a middle fielder this yr and, particularly if Severino can’t return to usefulness, maybe a starter. So until Hal Steinbrenner authorizes exceeding the brink — and he ought to try this if making an attempt to win a title is really the aim — then the Yanks will doubtless have a restricted pool from which to decide on and/or must make investments extra in prospect capital to get one other staff to eat {dollars}.

Boone acknowledged earlier than Thursday’s doubleheader towards the Blue Jays what was fairly apparent, that Hicks will miss the rest of the year after tearing the tendon sheath in his left wrist. The Yanks had traded Mike Tauchman earlier than Hicks was harm and misplaced their two minor league depth items in Greg Allen and Ryan LaMarre to harm. They called up Estevan Florial to outlive the doubleheader, however the staff doesn’t suppose he’s prepared. That leaves Gardner, at 37 by far the majors’ oldest heart fielder, as the choice. In dropping 2-0 to Toronto within the doubleheader opener, the Yanks managed two hits, none by Gardner, who’s all the way down to .198, and the staff’s heart fielders are at .190.

Gardner was final the unquestioned beginning heart fielder in 2013. He was really good at it. Nevertheless, the Yanks signed Jacoby Ellsbury for seven years at $153 million. That was a nasty concept. Yet, within the 4 seasons Ellsbury received on the sphere for the Yankees he performed extra video games for them (520) than Hicks has in six (493). They have the identical Wins Above Replacement as Yankees at 9.8. That is $223 million mixed for Ellsbury and Hicks, who had been simpler to trace for after they had been out there than the other. Hicks, who was hitting .194 in 32 video games this yr, nonetheless has 4 years at $40 million left after this season.

Severino is owed $11 million subsequent season, then has a $15 million 2023 choice or a $2.75 million buyout. As the righty rehabs from Tommy John surgical procedure, he threw two batting follow innings Wednesday and has basically a full spring coaching nonetheless in entrance of him. Boone indicated that the plan has at all times been for Severino to finish his rehab within the majors — so suppose simply three- or four-inning outings initially when he does arrive.

New York Yankees center fielder Aaron Hicks
Aaron Hicks
Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post

And the urgency for his return went up with Kluber (shoulder) not due back until about the trade deadline. Will Severino beat him? Will both truly pitch this yr? (Note that Noah Syndergaard, who underwent Tommy John surgical procedure about the identical time as Severino, had a setback that pushes him to round September.) Will the Yanks even know sufficient about Severino if he does return to maintain them out of the starter commerce market?

Hicks and Severino had been supposed to supply solutions and value certainty for years; that was the Yankee perception in doing the lengthy contracts early. Instead, they’ve prolonged the Yankees’ listing of issues.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.