Decoded | Why every OBC candidate does not get reservation benefit

The reservation debate is again in dialog primarily on account of a central authorities announcement for quota in MBBS and postgraduate medical programs for the OBC and Economically Weaker Section classes.

Currently, kids of individuals holding constitutional posts are included within the creamy layer and not entitled to OBC reservation advantages. (Representational)

Cream swims on prime of boiled milk. It is wealthy in fats. This imagery fits nicely to clarify why regardless of 27 per cent reservation for the Other Backward Classes (OBC) not every candidate from the class is entitled for quota in jobs and schooling.

The reservation debate is again in dialog primarily on account of a central government announcement for quota in MBBS and postgraduate medical courses for the OBC and Economically Weaker Section (EWS) classes, and 11 MPs from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the Congress and the Samajwadi Party elevating questions concerning the “creamy layer” within the ongoing Monsoon Session of Parliament.

So, what’s the creamy layer?

When 27 per cent reservation was introduced in for the OBCs — as per Mandal Commission report — in 1990, the availability for creamy layer was not there. All belonging to the OBC class had been entitled for reservation in authorities jobs and better academic establishments.

  • Through a Supreme Court judgment delivered in 1992 — well-known because the Indira Sawhney case wherein 27 per cent reservation for Socially and Economically Backward Classes (SEBC) was challenged — creamy layer was launched.
  • The creamy layer emerged as an idea to find out the brink for reservation eligibility inside the 27 per cent quota for the OBC class. Those categorized as belonging to the creamy layer had been denied the advantages of reservation.

The central authorities notified the operation of creamy layer on the recommendation of an knowledgeable committee headed by retired Justice RN Prasad. The creamy layer threshold grew to become operational in 1993.

So, who can’t declare quota benefit?

In September 1993, the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) notified a listing of classes of individuals defining their standing based mostly on rank in authorities jobs or earnings whose kids had been not to avail advantages of reservation in any other case out there to the OBC candidates.

The threshold for the listing has been modified for earnings bases. Currently, kids of individuals holding constitutional posts are included within the creamy layer and not entitled to OBC reservation advantages.

  • Children whose one dad or mum maintain authorities publish within the Group-A providers are included in creamy layer.
  • One exception is there: if the dad or mum entered Group-A by promotion after the age of 40, the kids may declare quota advantages.
  • If each dad and mom are within the Group-B providers, kids can’t declare reservation advantages.
  • For these not holding authorities posts, the creamy layer threshold is Rs 8 lakh annual earnings.
  • Agricultural earnings is not counted for figuring out creamy layer.

Is the creamy layer being modified once more?

This is up for debate. The authentic rollout of the creamy layer mandated the central authorities to revise the earnings threshold every three years. But the primary revision passed off after 11 years in 2004. Since then, it has been revised 3 times, the final was carried out in 2017 (Rs 8 lakh-bar).

Reports say the federal government is contemplating a proposal to revise earnings threshold for the creamy layer. There has been debate over whether or not earnings from agricultural processes must be included in it or not.

During the continued Monsoon Session, the social justice and empowerment ministry informed Parliament that “a proposal for revision of the income criteria for determining the creamy layer” among the many OBCs “is under consideration”.

There have additionally been complaints by the MPs belonging to the OBC class that the seats reserved for the OBC candidates had been being stuffed by basic class candidates citing lack of eligible candidates from the OBC class. This is more likely to be tackled when a contemporary resolution is taken on the creamy layer by the federal government.

Read: PM reviews OBC, EWS reservation in All India Quota for medical education

Read: NEET 2020: SC rejects plea for 50% reservation of medical college seats for OBC candidates in TN

Click right here for IndiaRight this moment.in’s complete coverage of the coronavirus pandemic.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.