No, social workers don’t do better than cops at mental-health response

Last month, New York City joined dozens of different cities experimenting with “alternatives” to policing by launching the Behavioral Health Emergency Assistance Response Division, or B-HEARD, in a pilot research in elements of Harlem. The program dispatches social workers and paramedics to sure mental-health-related 911 calls. Supporters argue that this strategy reorients the response to those calls, from public security towards public well being.

Now the mayor’s workplace has put out its first report on this system to a glowing, however deceptive, reception within the media.

Outlets similar to Business Insider and NPR highlighted the discovering that these approached by B-HEARD responders had been extra more likely to settle for assist than these approached by police. NBC New York recognized a causal relationship, claiming that B-HEARD is “reducing unnecessary hospitalizations, while increasing the percentage of people who accept help when offered.”

At first look, the outcomes look spectacular. Just 5 p.c of these approached by B-HEARD in its first month refused help, in contrast with 18 p.c who acquired a “traditional mental-health response” in the identical interval. And B-HEARD instances had been a lot much less more likely to be hospitalized.

Unfortunately, a more in-depth look at the information reported by the mayor’s workplace suggests a deck stacked for B-HEARD’s success. Responders seem to have acquired calls that had been — maybe unwittingly — chosen to supply better outcomes.

Officer Lamont Edwards talks to actor Nathan Purdee during a crisis intervention training class at the NYPD police academy.
Officer Lamont Edwards talks to actor Nathan Purdee throughout a disaster intervention coaching class at the NYPD police academy.

As the mayor’s report notes, the month following B-HEARD’s launch noticed roughly 500 mental-health-related calls within the lined space. Of these, roughly 1 / 4 had been referred to B-HEARD, which then kicked again an additional 1 in 5. In whole, the civilian responders thought of themselves in a position to deal with simply 107 calls, or about 21 p.c of the overall.

The calls referred to B-HEARD weren’t a random pattern. Responders weren’t routed calls “that involve a weapon, an imminent risk of violence or where NYPD or EMS call-takers know that an individual has an immediate need for transportation to a medical facility.” B-HEARD responders had been additionally on name for less than 16 hours a day; in the event that they took the evening off, they might have been spared coping with mental-health crises amongst people who had declined shelter for the night.

Hence an apples-to-apples comparability between B-HEARD and “traditional” response suffers from choice bias. The distinction in outcomes between the 2 teams owes at least partially, even principally, to the distinction between the swimming pools of calls that every is accountable for dealing with.

If the NYPD is known as in on extra critical and violent calls, the individuals with whom the police work together will likely be, on common, much less prepared to simply accept assist — no matter no matter methods cops use to de-escalate the state of affairs.

This sample is widespread throughout civilian-led mental-health-response initiatives. CAHOOTS, the unique various program from Eugene, Ore., is commonly touted as a mannequin for different cities seeking to scale back police exercise. But as my recent Manhattan Institute report found, CAHOOTS responders cowl fewer than 20 p.c of 911 calls, with 3 in 4 of these involving routine welfare checks or transporting homeless individuals.

Instructors go over a crisis intervention training lesson at the NYPD Police Academy.
Instructors go over a disaster intervention coaching lesson at the NYPD Police Academy.

Civilian options, in different phrases, take the simple calls and principally do a very good job. If cities need that, it’s not a foul use of assets — if something, it frees up cops’ time to deal with combating crime. But we should always not anticipate B-HEARD’s excessive charges of success to persist if it begins choosing up tougher calls.

The actuality is that police do a reasonably good job dealing with mental-health conditions, and unarmed civilian options will at all times be reliant on the police as a backup; B-HEARD sought help in seven of the 107 calls it managed.

Advocates of defunding police will level to B-HEARD’s success as proof that we are able to dramatically curtail policing, however let’s be clear about what the information present: We can trim across the edges, however civilians can’t substitute cops.

Charles Fain Lehman is a fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a contributing editor of City Journal, from which this column was tailored.

Twitter: @CharlesFLehman

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.