NY lawmakers’ ‘clean-slate’ proposal is a gift to criminals

Many states have so-called clean-slate legal guidelines. Second possibilities permit these with felony histories to search jobs, housing and academic alternatives. A previous felony historical past will be a barrier to getting again in your toes, even after remaining crime-free for many years.

New York already has a sealing statute, enacted in 2017 with help from state prosecutors, who stay dedicated to serving to folks navigate the method of sealing previous convictions. Prosecutors help second possibilities, and many lives within the Empire State could be remodeled by a rigorously thought-out clean-slate legislation that expands the universe of convictions that may be sealed. 

Sadly, the clean-slate proposal pending isn’t such a legislation.

The laws would routinely seal felony data for a sweeping checklist of crimes — after one 12 months for misdemeanors and three years for felonies. After 5 years, most misdemeanors could be routinely expunged, and after seven, many felonies. 

How this may play out isn’t clear. Typically, “expungement” means data are utterly destroyed and never out there to legislation enforcement, prosecutors or courts. Is that what lawmakers actually need? This additionally illogically signifies that some felony data might be sealed earlier than somebody completes his jail sentence.

Lawmakers in Albany ought to bear in mind lessons learned from bail “reform.” Soon after the state’s new bail legal guidelines went into impact, legislators realized that these accused of some crimes pose a danger to public security or won’t return to court docket and needs to be thought of for bail. The legislation was amended to permit bail for crimes comparable to residence burglaries, crimes that trigger loss of life and different severe crimes. 

All offenses shouldn’t be handled the identical. Some crimes pose a larger danger to public security. Clean-slate invoice sponsors agree and don’t need to permit intercourse offenders to profit from routinely erased felony data. But the invoice sponsors haven’t thought of the danger when it comes to homicide, theft, kidnapping, arson, assault, hate crimes, home violence crimes, drunk-or-drugged driving or gun offenses that will routinely be sealed after which destroyed. 

Plus, prosecutors have identified that the proposed clean-slate invoice requires expungement of “biometric information” but doesn’t outline the time period. This might imply destruction of DNA-database data that assist clear up serial sexual assaults and chilly instances, and so assist overturn convictions and supply proof for exonerations. Surely, our lawmakers don’t intend that.

NYPD at the scene of a shooting in a subway station in the Bronx on May 22, 2021.
NYPD on the scene of a capturing in a subway station within the Bronx on May 22, 2021.
Christopher Sadowski

Gun violence is plaguing all of our communities, but the invoice isn’t clear as to whether or not felony data will probably be made out there to the federal gun registry or gun registries of different states.

Commonsense clean-slate laws ought to permit employers to search data for particular offenses associated to sure areas of employment. This might embody these looking for jobs associated to baby care, elder care, transportation and monetary industries. Wouldn’t you need to know if the school-bus driver has repeated convictions for drunk driving? 

When adjustments to New York’s bail legislation have been being mentioned in Albany, authorized consultants pointed to states that reformed bail legal guidelines and received a lot proper. Recently, Michigan enacted a complete clean-slate legislation that comes with necessary safeguards, placing a steadiness in permitting extra folks to profit from sealed data whereas not serving to out profession criminals, power drunk drivers or different bad-faith repeat offenders. 

Michigan particularly excludes a checklist of crimes from sealing, comparable to DWI and sure felony domestic-violence crimes. Courts, legislation enforcers and prosecutors can nonetheless entry felony data. Michigan seals misdemeanors after seven years, versus simply a 12 months as proposed in New York; felonies are sealed after 10 years, quite than the three proposed in our state. Michigan, furthermore, places limits on the variety of convictions eligible for automated sealing, in order that profession criminals don’t get pleasure from third, fourth or twentieth possibilities. 

Albany should take into account some adjustments to the pending clean-slate legislation. Those who’ve paid their debt to society ought to have the option to transfer on — profession criminals shouldn’t. 

Morgan Bitton is govt ­director of the District Attorneys Association of the State of New York.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.