‘Outdated’: Radiologists refute AIIMS director’s remark on CT scans

The Radiology and Imaging Association of India has refuted claims made by the AIIMS director’s that Computerised Tomography or CT scans are extraordinarily dangerous. This concept is ‘outdated’, the docs’ physique stated in a press release.

The assertion got here in response to an interview given by Dr Randeep Guleria to India Today TV the place the AIIMS director warned towards ‘overtreatment’, saying that CT scans needs to be prevented until prescribed by a medical practitioner. He said those patients having mild Covid-19 symptoms are doing more harm by exposing themselves to radiation generated by a CT scan, and that this escalates the chance of most cancers.

Dr Randeep Guleria stated within the interview that one CT scan is equal to 300-400 chest X-rays and this will increase the chance of getting most cancers in later life, particularly among the many youth as a consequence of publicity to dangerous radiation. “If you are in doubt, then go for a chest X-ray first. If necessary, the doctor will give proper advice whether a CT scan is needed or not,” Dr Guleria had advised India Today TV.

The radiology physique on Wednesday launched a press release and condemned AIIMS director’s assertion on CT scans.


Why CT Scan?

The RT-PCR take a look at is the investigation of selection for diagnosing Covid-19 sufferers. A CT scan, nevertheless, is used within the prognosis of sufferers, who’ve typical options of Covid however are RT-PCR adverse as a consequence of mutant variant, technical errors or low viral load. A CT scan helps to diagnose these sufferers and early detection helps to start out remedy and stops them from being super-spreaders.

While RT-PCR helps within the prognosis, CT scan helps to stage the severity of illness, particularly in symptomatic sufferers. The CT rating given for Covid-19 sufferers helps to provoke remedy. This rating helps docs determine if the affected person will be in house quarantine or wants hospital admission.

How is it useful?

A CT scan of the chest helps in understanding whether or not the illness is delicate, reasonable, or extreme by contributing considerably in administration. Moreover, the development of the illness will be monitored by CT, particularly in sufferers who’re deteriorating.

In a illness like Covid 19, which has an unpredictable course, figuring out at-risk people early and well timed initiation of remedy is of utmost significance. The IRIA stated a CT scan is way extra delicate than saturation monitoring by pulse oximetry in detecting lung harm, within the early part of the illness.

Initiating steroids on the proper time can halt the development of lung involvement earlier than saturation begins falling. Already hospitals are overburdened and with early administration of remedy, it may be attainable to handle the affected person at house. The sooner the remedy is began, simpler it’s to save lots of a affected person, the physique stated in a press release.

Now younger folks current with completely satisfied hypoxia (when sufferers have low oxygen saturation however don’t really feel any signs) and they don’t get alarmed until the illness has progressed with extreme harm to the lungs. This is frequent with younger sufferers who can stand up to as much as SpO2 of 80 per cent, whereas older folks can stand up to as much as 90 per cent SpO2.

Also Watch: When to go for a CT scan? All your queries answered

‘Can be Performed Quickly’

CT chest will be carried out rapidly particularly in emergencies when the RT-PCR report takes time, and initiation of early remedy is required. A CT scan helps to alert the clinician of a suspicious affected person, thus stopping the publicity.

It additionally helps to diagnose a number of circumstances that mimic Covid-19 like different bacterial and viral infections, cardiac failure, and many others, the physique stated.

CT Chest vs Chest X-ray

The classical characteristic of Covid-19 is the bottom glass opacities seen within the sub-pleural area particularly within the decrease lobes. Several research have concluded that Chest X-ray is ineffective within the prognosis of early Covid and can be utilized solely within the following of sufferers with extreme Covid-19 pneumonia to observe development. The research exhibits that CT scanning has demonstrated glorious sensitivity and may strongly be thought-about through the pandemic within the preliminary evaluation of COVID-19. This must be balanced towards the chance of extra radiation with CT, the place capability permits.

Radiation in CT Imaging

Dr Randeep Guleria had claimed that one CT chest is the same as 300-400 X-rays. “This is a very retrograde statement and was the situation 30-40 years ago. The modern CT scanners use ultra low dose CT, which has radiation comparable to only 5 to 10 X-rays. “ the body clarified. Radiologists all over the world follow the ALARA principle (As Low As Reasonably Achievable) and give the minimal radiation possible during the scan.

Technology has Reduced the Risk

The IRIA said that with the advent of low-dose CT techniques and advancement in the software’, the dose is reduced to one third to one fourth and with ultra low dose CT scan, we can reduce to one-tenth. “The medical investigations and treatment are also analysed based on the risk vs benefit ratio and is very clear in this case the benefit far outweighs the risk, which is almost non-existent.”

Also, the assertion that CT Chest may cause Lung Cancer is alarming. The radiation dose from a single CT chest is nearly equal to the background radiation acquired by any particular person over a 12 months.

Speaking to India Today, Dr Meinal Chaudhry, director radiodiagnosis, Aakash Healthcare stated, “CT scan is definitely harmful if it is done without a doctor’s prescription. We should understand that a CT scan is not a substitute for RT-PCR. It has its own role in the management of Covid and whenever prescribed by the doctor, it can also alter the management given to a patient by the doctor. It is my appeal to the people to not get CT scan done as per their own wish.”

A CT scan will not be an alternative to RT-PCR, say consultants. CT scan has its personal function within the administration of Covid-19 and may alter the administration protocol when achieved in the correct time and when prescribed by personal practitioners. Only go for a CT scan when it’s prescribed by a medical practitioner.

Also Read | India may see 3rd Covid wave, no point of night curfews, weekend lockdowns: AIIMS chief Randeep Guleria

Also Read | Where are Covid-19 foreign aid supplies going? Opposition asks Centre to make details public

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.