Perception vs reality: Covid-19 relief supplies from China are purchases not aid

In the previous weeks, social media platforms have been flooded with messages of Covid relief supplies coming to India and the function of China in offering help. But, the very fact is that each one the supplies are business procurements, which are purchased from China both by governments or personal entities.

Not single medical tools imported to India is a ‘grant’ from China. But, Chinese envoy to India Ambassador Sun Weidong hasn’t as soon as talked about in his tweets that they are business purchases.

One have a look at his Twitter timeline would make anybody imagine that Beijing is the largest donor of apparatus to India.

His final tweet was about native “cooperation” between the 2 nations in response to the tweet of the Chinese Consul General in Kolkata mentioning the arrival of oxygen concentrators within the metropolis.

“Local areas cooperation between China & India also plays an important role in fighting #COVID19,” tweeted Ambassador Weidong.

Zha Liyou, China’s Consul General in Kolkata, had written: “My friend told me the 2nd batch of oxygen concentrators made by the same company in Henan, China went through customs clearance yesterday. Should be arriving in Kolkata May 4 (Today). At this difficult time, what matters most is saving lives, whoever capable of. #StayStrongIndia”

This is a part of China’s technique to mission aid coming from China as Chinese aid, however there’s a big distinction. Sources affirm to India Today TV that Beijing has provided help and help on a couple of event however New Delhi is “yet to respond”.

Former Intelligence Officer and a China skilled, Jayadev Ranade mentioned: “China’s actions even at this time of humanitarian crisis reveals the Chinese regime’s true nature!”

One of the reviews in a Chinese information web site ( reads: “From April 22 to May 1, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs held 7 press conferences and expressed condolences to India 7 times, emphasising that China is willing to provide assistance within its capacity china expressed goodwill seven times in a row. But there was no clear statement from India.”

The piece acknowledges India’s help by means of medical supplies final 12 months through the Wuhan lockdown after which provides “Now, China has shown the greatest patience and goodwill,” performing as a significant energy. And then it bemoans that each India and China lose out once they are preventing, “which is exactly what some countries want.”

But, the Twitter thread of the Chinese envoy continues unabated. In one in every of his tweets he says, “As far as it goes. #China provides most oxygen concentrators to #India, and keeps producing oxygen concentrators & other medical equipment for India.”

This one would make one really feel that it was being completed as humanitarian work and there’s no revenue element to the transaction.

“Chinese companies carry forward the spirit of humanitarianism, focus on saving lives, respond to wants & needs of the Indian people. That reveals their social responsibilities as well as the goodwill in helping India fight #COVID19. Thumbs up for what they have done.

Despite problems in relations, China is the only country that produces these critical medical equipment is the reason why there is a growing call from other quarters to strengthen alternative supply chains.

Manoj Kewalramani, Fellow-China Studies, Takshashila Institute, explains, “The crisis in India allows China to gain commercially through sale of medical supplies, equipment and therapeutics and geopolitically by highlighting its goodwill, willingness and capacity to address the needs of countries in the region, and its reliability and centrality in key supply chains.”

There have been reviews of costs being jacked up by Chinese firms for oxygen-related tools being procured from China by governments and personal sector.

In truth, lately US firms complained of their shipments being delayed or barred from sending to India immediately and needed to be rerouted by means of different nations.

Actor Sonu Sood had additionally tweeted looking for assist from the Chinese mission in New Delhi to assist clear their shipments caught in China that might save lives.

This even because the mission denied any function of the Chinese authorities in inflicting delays to the supply of consignments to India.

Gave an interview to @globaltimesnews yesterday. Humanity is a group with a shared future, saving lives is of paramount significance. Pls learn the complete textual content: m9q.internet/m21af

“There has been significant outreach from the Chinese government since late April. It is clear that Beijing would like to play an active and public role in assisting India deal with the second wave. This, of course, is driven by its own interest calculations. Thus far, all deliveries from China have been a result of commercial deals,” mentioned Kewalramani.

Adding, “This aspect, however, has generally been either omitted or downplayed in public communication. In saying this, it is important to note that Beijing has sent clear signals that it would like extend government-level support and aid, but it appears that the Indian side has been reluctant to go down that road.”

The messaging clearly is to painting China as a rustic working for humanity and not revenue, whereas in actuality, each final buck is paid for the tools coming to India.

“Workers of a Chinese oxygen generator manufacturer are working overtime to produce & pack the machines on #MayDay holiday. This batch of oxygen generators will be sent to #India soon.”

This whilst Chinese President Xi Jinping and overseas minister Wang Yi have reached out to their Indian counterpart expressing “solidarity”.

“Chinese companies have been accelerating production of at least 40,000 oxygen generators orders placed by Indian side & are working at a fast pace to deliver asap. Many Chinese firms&private organizations are also using their own channels to provide various help to India.”

“Since this April, #China has supplied more than 5000 ventilators, 21569 oxygen generators, over 21.48 million masks & around 3800 tons of medicines to #India, according to statistics of the General Administration of Customs of China.”

China is vital to ease the struggling in India and has been guaranteeing movement of those business procurements, however attempting to make it appear like a bilateral association and omitting the important transactional nature of the provision, is deceptive, to say the least.

ALSO READ: Indian Air Force clocks 500 hours of airlifting oxygen containers, medical supplies amid Covid crisis

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.