Yankees’ 2017 loss to Astros one of NY baseball’s big what-ifs

“Of all of the phrases of tongue and pen

“The saddest are these: It might have been”

– Felix Unger, 1972

– John Greenleaf Whittier, 1856

For sports activities followers, the easier lament is that this: “What if?”

What-ifs dominate the dialog round water coolers, alongside saloon tables, in textual content threads. Sports followers love speaking concerning the championships their groups have gained; they dwell to bewail the titles that had been stolen, taken or just denied via a merciless sequence of incidents and accidents and plain rotten luck.

The Astros’ appearance at Yankee Stadium this week for the primary time because it was revealed they had been — cough, cough — aided and abetted in successful the 2017 ALCS in seven memorable video games from the Yankees was merely the newest bewilderment to befall our baseball groups. It is a reasonably tortured listing.

What if these ’17 video games had been performed on the up-and-up? It is a good and everlasting query, and the most effective (or, relying in your perspective) worst sort of what-if: We don’t know that it will’ve performed out as we suspect it will’ve performed out. But good luck promoting us that any of these wouldn’t have every ended someplace shut to fortunately ever after.

What if …

The Astros hadn’t cheated in 2017?

For the report, they insist they didn’t cheat within the ’17 postseason. I’ll pause as you guffaw at that. Look: The Yankees nonetheless took a 3-2 lead again to Houston for Game 6, and had been stopped as a lot by the 1-2-3 pitching punch of Justin Verlander, Charlie Morton and Lance McCullers Jr. in these remaining two video games — scoring one run, whole — as something.

But whenever you begin sliding doorways, you invite all the things inside. So it’s value remembering that the Yankees obtained good pitching themselves in Games 1 and a couple of of the sequence, however nonetheless misplaced matching 2-1 video games, together with Game 2 when Jose Altuve and Carlos Correa reached Aroldis Chapman and his 102-mph kerosene for ninth-inning hits.

The Yankees had bunted on Curt Schilling in 2004?

You can legit drive your self batty taking place the rabbit gap of the ’04 ALCS. What if Jorge Posada’s throw within the ninth inning of Game 4 is a millimeter faster? What if Joe Torre summons Mariano Rivera sooner than he did in Game 5? What if the umps — pre-replay — don’t overturn two separate calls in Game 6 that benefitted the Sox (most notably the Alex Rodriguez Slap Play)?

But the query that continues to be unanswered all these years later is: Why not make Schilling and his fixed-with-tape-and-staples ankle work somewhat bit in Game 6? Why not bunt just a few occasions, make Schilling uncomfortable? Maybe Schilling shakes that off and nonetheless provides us The Bloody Sock Masterpiece. But perhaps it wrecks him; the Yankees did tattoo him for six runs in three innings in Game 1, in any case.

Duaner Sanchez hadn’t gotten hungry in Miami in 2006?

The ’06 Mets had been as full an version as that workforce has fielded since 1986. They had been rolling via the common season. Then Sanchez, who’d been just about unhittable as Billy Wagner’s main setup man, obtained a jones for Dominican meals early within the morning of July 30, his taxi was hit by a drunk driver, he separated his shoulder and was misplaced for the yr.

As damaging as dropping Sanchez was what the Mets did to compensate: They traded stable, regular proper fielder Xavier Nady to Pittsburgh for bullpen assist (Roberto Hernandez and Oliver Perez). The Mets missed Nady badly within the postseason, by no means greater than when Shawn Green misplayed a key fly ball right into a triple in Game 2 of the NLCS, which instantly turned the entire sequence the wrong way up.

Mariano Rivera and Buck Showalter in 2013
Getty Images

Buck Showalter knew what Mariano Rivera actually was?

The 1995 ALDS was thrilling from begin to end nevertheless it ended with each Showalter and Don Mattingly (enjoying his final sport) in tears. Rivera, who usually pitched a number of innings in that his rookie yr, was lifted within the tenth inning of a 4-4 Game 5 after dealing with however 4 hitters. The Yanks took a 5-4 lead within the prime of the eleventh and Showalter didn’t belief John Wetteland so he had to stick with Jack McDowell, a starter who’d relieved Rivera. Surely if Showalter knew what Rivera would grow to be — just about untouchable in October — McDowell by no means would’ve been summoned and allowed to give up the 2 runs that clinched the Seattle comeback within the backside of the eleventh.

Bobby Murcer hadn’t tried to be a peacemaker?

The Yankees stole New York again from the Mets all throughout 1974, and on Sept. 29, they landed in Milwaukee a half-game out of first place with two video games left, on the verge of breaking a 10-year playoff drought. But on the Pfister Hotel, backup catchers Bill Sudakis and Rick Dempsey obtained right into a combat, Murcer tried to break it up and obtained a damaged finger as an alternative. Murcer had endured a tough season, however was nonetheless the guts of the workforce; the Yankees by no means did catch the Orioles. A number of weeks later he was traded to San Francisco.

Yogi Berra hadn’t listened to Tom Seaver?

This one’s a subset of the best Mets what-if of all: What if Gil Hodges hadn’t died at 48 on Easter Sunday 1972?

The Mets had been set: Up 3-2 within the 1973 World Series, flying again to Oakland, and Yogi was planning on beginning George Stone (12-3 that yr) with Seaver prepared on full relaxation to pitch Game 7 if wanted. But a while throughout the flight, Seaver talked Yogi into giving him the ball in Game 6 on three days’ relaxation. How do you say no to The Franchise? (Spoiler alert: Gil would’ve discovered a manner.) Seaver pitched superb in Game 6, however wasn’t his dominant self and the Mets misplaced, 3-1. Then Jon Matlack was flattened in Game 7. The Miracle Mets would have solely one title to present for an amazin’ period.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.